What is an expectation, and when does it become a problem?
An expectation is, at its core, nothing more than a specific perception of how something should be or how someone should behave so that we feel good. Anyone who hopes that their boss will treat them with respect or that their child will do their homework in the afternoon is simply holding a completely neutral view. Nobody needs to justify this, because we are human beings and we have the capacity to imagine things.
An expectation only becomes a problem when it comes up against a reality that looks different. The boss isn’t respectful; the child refuses to cooperate and doesn’t think about their homework. This is where perception and reality collide. The word ‘conflict’ comes from the Latin ‘conflictus’ and means a clash or collision. This image fits remarkably well with what is happening inside us.
What happens in the gap between expectation and reality?
Our minds immediately fill with assumptions because we want to understand why things turned out differently. Why isn’t my boss supporting me? Why didn’t my colleague say hello to me in the corridor? Why isn’t he replying to my email?
These assumptions are rarely neutral. Within seconds, ‘She didn’t say hello to me’ becomes ‘She’s angry with me’. An unanswered email becomes ‘He couldn’t care less about my problem’. Assumptions turn into judgements, and sometimes they are even directed against ourselves: ‘I’m simply not good enough.’ Doubt, insecurity and withdrawal then follow.
A typical example: A manager sends a message on Friday evening asking someone to complete a task. The recipient interprets this as ‘by Monday’ and is annoyed that their weekend has been disrupted. Perhaps the manager simply meant: ‘I just wanted to get it off my mind; Wednesday will do.’ The expectation was never explicitly stated; it was merely assumed.
What are the three main areas of expectation?
To understand where the pressure comes from, it helps to identify the nature of the expectation. There are three:
- Expectations you have of yourself: You demand perfection, constant availability or flawless work from yourself.
- Expectations of others: You assume that colleagues, partners or superiors will behave in a certain way.
- Others’ expectations of you: You sense that someone is expecting something of you, even if it has never been said out loud.
The nature of the problem determines where you need to start. When it comes to the expectations you have of yourself, you need a more realistic yardstick. When it comes to the expectations you have of others, you need a clarifying conversation. And when it comes to what you suspect others expect of you, you need one thing above all else: to ask for clarification.
How do we react when expectations are not met?
When reality does not match their expectations, most people unconsciously fall back on one of three patterns.
- Demanding that others adapt: The attitude is, ‘My expectations are the right ones, so you have to change.’
- Adapting oneself: Those who prioritise harmony above all else think, ‘Well, I’ll just have to do a bit better then.’
- Taking on the role of the victim: Here, no accusations are made and nothing changes. One withdraws and secretly finds the others difficult to deal with.
None of these patterns is a character flaw. They often stem from experiences that protected us in the past. However, they do not resolve the conflict because they bypass the crux of the matter: an open discussion about what is expected.
There is almost always fear behind this. We fear disappointment, judgement, arguments or being excluded from the group. And fear robs us of precisely the control we need to remain objective.
What is the cost of unclarified expectations in day-to-day working life?
Conflicts are not a marginal issue. The 2009 KPMG study on the costs of conflict – the largest of its kind in Germany to date – concludes that, on average, 10 to 15 per cent of working time in companies is spent dealing with conflicts. Among managers, the proportion of time lost to friction is as high as 30 to 50 per cent. Although the study is some time ago, it clearly shows how much time and energy is lost due to unresolved tensions. According to the same study, effective conflict management can reduce costs by at least 25 per cent.
A significant proportion of these costs does not arise from genuine differences of opinion. It arises because nobody has made it clear who expects what. A customer contacts the company in a huff because nobody has informed them of a delay. The sales team says it’s a matter for Customer Service. Customer Service refers the matter to the project manager. Nobody has done anything wrong, but everyone has tacitly expected someone else to sort it out. It is the customer who pays the price.
How does expectation management help to defuse a conflict?
Expectation management means recognising, articulating and clarifying expectations before assumptions take over. A simple way to do this is to ask yourself three questions (from my ‘Black Box’ method) before you react:
What exactly is happening right now? Describe only what you can observe, without judgement. For example: ‘My colleague interrupted me three times during the meeting.’
Who expects what from whom here? Check which expectations you know for certain and which you’re merely assuming.
What am I actually afraid of? Identify the concern behind the uneasy feeling.
This analysis creates some distance between the trigger and your reaction. Very often, it becomes clear that the situation is less serious than you thought.acht, weil die vermutete Erwartung des anderen nie existierte oder die Angst unrealistisch war.
Only then does the second step follow: the conversation. If you ask questions rather than making assumptions, you stay focused on the facts. Questions such as the following are helpful:
- What do you need from me to enable you to work effectively?
- What exactly do you mean by that? Can you give an example?
- What concerns do you have?
- What can I do to allay those concerns?
Is a conflict really the problem?
A conflict isn’t automatically a sign of a failed relationship. Two people can disagree and still work together brilliantly. It only becomes a problem when their relationship deteriorates – when they no longer greet one another, make snide remarks in meetings, or talk behind each other’s backs. Then a matter of fact turned into a relationship conflict.
The real danger, therefore, lies in silence. Anyone who keeps their opinions to themselves for fear of conflict may spare themselves some short-term unease, but in the long run they pay the price in misunderstandings, withdrawal and a breakdown in cooperation. Healthy relationships are not conflict-free, but honest and secure. In them, it is acceptable to disagree, to make mistakes and to admit that you are having a bad day.
Conflicts usually arise not from the people themselves, but from unspoken expectations that clash with a different reality and are coloured by assumptions and judgements. Those who recognise their expectations, ask questions about them and address them openly approach difficult conversations with less anxiety and build relationships in which clarity and trust become the norm..
Sources
- KPMG Study on the Costs of Conflict (2009), reproduced by Büro-Kaizen: Konfliktmanagement in Unternehmen